I debated back and forth between the 58 and 75 and finally settled on the 58 due to the size being better for the boat and other activities. Ordered the stick on mat for seating and standing on it to cast, and the basket. It all works great! Orca stayed in touch with me through the whole process and it all arrived quickly and together in one box. If your debating purchase, stop and just order it. Ice retention is better than all the competitors and made in the USA!